Psychology Reader

Family-Based and Individual Treatment for Adolescent Anorexia Nervosa

James Lock, Daniel Le Grange, W. Stewart Agras, and 3 others · 2010 · Archives of General Psychiatry

Role
Methodological contribution
Difficulty
Moderate
Full work length
8 pages
Type
Journal article

Access

Psychology Reader links to legitimate sources and does not host article PDFs.

Reading focus

Syllabus: How Can Couples, Families and Groups Become Settings for Change?

Follow the remission definitions and the contribution of parents in both treatment conditions.

Why you’re reading it. Evaluate a particular use of family participation rather than a general claim about families.

A question to consider. What would you add to this evaluation to learn whether gains for the adolescent came with increased or reduced caregiver burden?

Why this reading

This trial compares two ways of organizing help for adolescents with anorexia nervosa. It shows why treatment conclusions depend on the definition of improvement and when it is assessed.

Before you read

Full remission here combines a weight threshold with an eating-disorder assessment. A categorical threshold differs from a continuous change score. The individual treatment also includes parent meetings; the comparison is not family contact versus none.

Read for

  1. Identify what differs between the treatments and what medical support both receive.
  2. Compare full remission, partial remission and continuous outcomes across follow-up.

Consider afterwards

  1. How could treatments have similar average scores but different remission rates?
  2. Which family and adolescent outcomes would add to the reported picture?

Editorial context

The 121 participants were treated at two specialist centers. The primary full-remission difference was not statistically significant at treatment end but favored family-based treatment at follow-up. Medical monitoring, sample selection and the limited follow-up constrain transfer to other settings. This is a package comparison, not a test that families caused the disorder.